This is the first test of the Spam Guard (for blogs). Before being able to leave a comment on this blog, you now have to copy a number (from an image) into a text box. Feel free to give it a try : ) It shouldn't allow the post if you don't type in the right code. At the moment the image isn't auto-generated, but obviously that won't be much of a trick - gif, swf or otherwise. If there are no kinks I'll submit this to the people at .Text if they are interested. It is REALLY easy to put this type of thing into blog software - in fact the biggest problem I had was that I am one version behind them with Visual Studio, so it took a bit of fussing to load their solution.

Essentially you just insert the image, field, and instructions stubs into the page that generates the comment. Then you generate an image based on a random number, and save it to the server. The comment page then gets displayed. When the comment is submitted, the submitted Spam Guard field is compared with the previously generated number, and the comment will only be added if there is a match. To be honest, you could probably skip the whole image thing, and just have the instructions say something like: "type 'no spam' into the following textbox", or "What is two plus 3?".

If anyone is having trouble posting, my e-mail is robin@debreuil.com...

Thanks to aSH and Brajeshwar for all their input : ).

posted on Sunday, November 02, 2003 8:46 AM
Feedback
  • # re: Spam Guard for Blogs
    Robin Debreuil
    Posted @ 11/2/2003 8:55 AM
    well, just to make sure!


  • # re: Spam Guard for Blogs
    Owen van Dijk
    Posted @ 11/2/2003 9:50 AM
    A few weeks ago i found a neat .NET component that did just that, generation of anti-spam images. But since i left my memory a few years ago at a legendary party, i can't find the URL anymore. I found an alternative here -> http://www.codeproject.com/aspnet/antiauto.asp

    Live Demo -> http://www.oobaloo.co.uk/AntiAuto

  • # re: Spam Guard for Blogs
    Robin Debreuil
    Posted @ 11/2/2003 10:28 AM
    Lol, I seems to me I lost something at a legendary party once too ; ).

    Nice link! I've seen those images used before too, I just can't remember where I first saw them - it was at least in the dotcom days anyway. It seems to me they were pretty common for something, but I forget what. Maybe it was hotmail..?

    I think I'm going to try it on my email too. One neat thing is you could develop peer group type networks while you were filtering spam - eg I could trust all the people my freinds trust. You could even rank the trust/closness of the group memebers, like a personal google weighted p2p network or something... It might be easier to just identifiy all the humans on the net, than to weed out the spammers ; )



  • # re: Spam Guard for Blogs
    Emma
    Posted @ 11/2/2003 11:28 AM
    Depending on just how persistent spammers are one could also use a set of tick boxes and something telling you which ones to click. Eiter text like above, or simply a row of a few tick boxes and a symbol over them telling you to mark it.

  • # re: Spam Guard for Blogs
    Owen van Dijk
    Posted @ 11/2/2003 11:52 AM
    Yeah,Hotmail uses it too.

    Currently going through all my bookmarks, since it was a really nice component. You had all these parameters, for example if you wanted b&w or colour, upper/lowercase, charset boundary settings, amount of grain and so on.

    The search continues :)

  • # re: Spam Guard for Blogs
    Robin Debreuil
    Posted @ 11/3/2003 4:52 PM
    test

  • # re: Spam Guard for Blogs
    Robin Debreuil
    Posted @ 11/5/2003 2:36 AM
    Just read on http://voisen.org that Robert Hall has a similar system (and more) in place http://www.impossibilities.com/blog/entry_blog-127.php

    If everyone had this would there still be blog spam? I don't think so, but I recently learned that .Text also has a comment API that this system would not circumvent. Well, maybe once every hole is plugged - like that ever happens. Still spammers are opportunists, make it too hard and they will go back to living with their fellow cockroaches.

  • # Blog Spam
    .Avery Blog
    Posted @ 1/13/2004 9:30 PM


  • # Blog Spam
    .Avery Blog
    Posted @ 1/13/2004 9:30 PM


Blog Stats

  • Posts - 121
  • Stories - 1
  • Comments - 1441
  • Trackbacks - 47

.Net Blogs

01101 Blogs

Flash Blogs

Graphics

People